[Deliverables and queries] [Presentation] [Homepage] |
Introduction
The subproject "Review of the historical seismicity
in the Gulf of Cadiz area before the 1 Nov. 1755 earthquake" is included
in a more vast project - "Review of historical seismicity in Europe" - the
aim of which is to establish a common methodology among European seismologists
and historians on research of historical seismicity and to get a significant
set of data on earthquake potential and effects. In this report, which
corresponds to the whole period of the execution of the project (1989-91),
are referred the main results obtained. The execution of this project is
under the responsibility of the National Institute for Meteorology and Geophysics
of Portugal and the National Geographic Institute of Spain. It is believed
that the long-term precedent research carried out in Portugal immediately
before the beginning of this project (Moreira, 1984; 1991; Runa e Morais
Freire, 1985; Themudo Barata et al., 1988; 1989) and by Pereira de Sousa
(1919-32) in the second and third decades of the present century led to the
acquisition of a large part of the existing data about the earthquakes that
occurred after the 16th century. Anyway, research in libraries and archives
continued both in Portugal and Spain during the period covered by this project
and several reports were produced showing the results. Meetings to examine
the state-of-the-art of the project and define the methodology, in which
participated Dr. Stucchi, coordinator of the project "Review of historical
seismicity in Europe", Dr. Paola Albini, historian who assists Dr. Stucchi,
the Portuguese and Spanish groups were held in Lisbon in 1989 and 1990. In
1989 and 1990 was paid special attention to the research in archives and
libraries in Algarve and Alentejo - the southernmost provinces of Portugal
- the most affected regions by earthquakes which occurred in the period covered
by the project. In Spain a research was carried out in 1990 in several archives
and libraries of the southwestern part of the country (Moreira, 1990). In
the last part of 1990 and 1991 was made an intense research in the National
Archive of Torre do Tombo in Lisbon, looking for documentation of the main
convents and for documentation left by diarists, journalists, members of
the diplomatic body and other erudite people, following the recommendations
of Dr. Stucchi in his note of June 1990 "Remarks and recommendations after
the first year".
Historical Research. Methodology
The first work which was carried out for the
execution of this project was the collection of all available data which
had already been obtained from the precedent long-term research carried out
by historians and seismologists (Moreira, 1984; 1991; Themudo Barata et al.,
1988; 1989). With these data was possible to do a basic catalogue for the
Gulf of Cadiz area covering the period of the project (Moreira, 1992). The
following step was to try to get more information looking for contemporary
press reports and manuscripts that could exist in the main libraries and
archives in southern Portugal. One historian carried out research of this
type in libraries and archives during about one year in Algarve and Alentejo
(Ferrão, 1989a; 1989b; 1990a; 1990b).
Some information was found about small earthquakes
which occurred during the period of the project. This research was carried
out mainly in 1989 and 1990. During this period was also prepared a study
on the religious settlement, showing the distribution of the military orders,
monasteries, centres of clerical administration, convents and other institutions
all over the country, that could have worked as macroseismic observatories
and therefore could furnish information on the main earthquakes felt during
the period of the project (Fig. 1). Based on the report presented by the
historian who carried out that work (Moreira, 1990), an intensive research
was carried out in the National Archive of Torre do Tombo in Lisbon with
the aim of obtaining information from documents written by people who lived
in the institutions above referred and that surely felt the earthquakes that
occurred in that time, especially the earthquake of 27 Dec. 1722. To do this
work different types of sources were searched, as follows: contemporary letters,
eye-witnesses reports, invoices of sums paid to repair damaged buildings,
contemporary texts with religious or religious and economical tendency,
non-contemporary texts containing transcriptions of contemporary
manuscripts.
This research could also select the places to
get data if we could infer the way that some documentation followed. Among
others, documentation of the following convents and monasteries was
consulted:
-
Avis: S. Bento convent
-
Beja: N. Sra. da Conceição
convent, Santa Clara convent
-
Estremoz: S. Francisco convent
-
Évora: N. Sra. do Espinheiro
convent, Sta. Clara convent, S. João Evangelista convent, N. Sra.
do Paraiso monastery
-
Faro: Sto. António convent,
Ordem Terceira da Penitência convent
-
Lagoa: Carmo convent
-
Lisboa: S. Francisco convent, S.
Bento convent
-
Marvão: N. Sra. da Estrela
convent
-
Sertã: Sto. António
convent
-
Setubal: Sta. Teresa de Jesus
convent
-
Tavira: S. Francisco
convent
-
Tibães: S. Martinho convent
In this documentation was found some information
about the 1 Nov. 1755 earthquake. It was also found information about an
obscure earthquake occurred in June 1769 (ANTT, 1776-1808). Till now it was
only known that that earthquake had been felt in Lisbon without any damage.
The new information shows that was also felt in Setúbal where it caused
destructions. Its epicentre is probably localized in the same area of the
11 Nov. 1858 earthquake. It was supposed that diplomatic correspondence could
give useful information. The following diplomatic correspondence was
consulted:
"Correspondence sent to the Portuguese Legation
in London" (1723-1725, 1737-1741);
"Legation of Portugal in Hague": correspondence
sent to several consuls (1819-1826) and correspondence received from several
consuls (1802-1824);
"Legation of Portugal in London": letters sent
to several people;
"Consulate of Portugal in Cadiz": several
documentation, private correspondence (1834-1837).
In this documentation was not found any reference
to earthquakes or any reference which could lead to the localization of any
document, interesting this project, in another archive. Documentation from
centres of clerical administration and religious orders was also
consulted.
It was supposed that the archives of the only
Portuguese newspaper that was published in the first half of the 18th century
- Gazeta de Lisboa - could give some information. Unhappily that archive
was not yet found till now. The same happens with the documentation left
by diarists.
Anyway, as a result of this research some
information was found to join to the basic catalogue that was referred in
the beginning of this paragraph, but most of the information that was found
is concerned with the 1755 earthquake. Information about the 1 Nov. 1755
earthquake itself was not considered for this project but all the available
data on precursory phenomena of this earthquake were collected (Fig. 2).
Details are given in Tabb. 1 and 2.
PLACE | PRECURSOR | ANTICIPATION | SOURCE |
Madrid and suburbs |
Turbid waters in wells Fetid waters in wells Fall of the water level in wells Decrese of the flow of the waters in springs and fountains |
Several days |
Amezua, 1755, p. 1 |
Alcalá |
Unusual gas exhalations (a kind of fog) |
Several days | Moreira de Mendonça, 1758 (p. 254) |
Cadiz | Crawling worms came out of the holes | 8 days | Kant, 1910 a,b |
PLACE | PRECURSOR | ANTICIPATION | SOURCE |
Lisbon |
Abnormal taste of water from wells Unusual gas exhalations (dark yellow smoke) Unusual animal behaviour (agitation) |
Several days before the earthquake Observed on the eve at 17:00 A short time before the earthquake |
Morerira de Mendonça, 1758 Moreira de Mendonça, 1758 (p.237) Moreira de Mendonça, 1758 (p.260) |
Alenquer | Unusual gas exhalations (sudden appearance of vapour) | A short time before the earthquake | Gazeta de Lisboa, 1756 |
Aveiro |
Smell to sulphur Turbid waters |
On the eve of the earthquake |
Enquire ordered by the Marquis of Pombal (Runa e Morais Freire, 1985) |
Évora | Fetid water in one well | Some months before the earthquake | Parochial reports (Alcaria Ruiva, Pereira de Sousa, 1919-1932) |
Portalegre | Unusual animal behaviour (animals came out of the roles) | Not known | Enquire ordered by the Marquis of Pombal (Runa e Morais Freire, 1985) |
A catalogue of aftershocks of the 1 Nov. 1755
earthquake with the corresponding descriptions and references was prepared
(Moreira, 1992).
On the other hand, documentation about the 31
March 1761 earthquake which was found during this research was considered
and included in this project. This earthquake which is considered by many
authors as a late aftershock of the 1 Nov. 1755 earthquake (Montandon, 1953;
Mezcua y Martinez Solares, 1983) reveals, in the light of the new data, that
really appears not to be.
The most striking point is that no data from
Algarve were found till now.
This fact, conjugated with the circumstance
that the 1761 earthquake was stronger at Oporto than the 1755 earthquake,
was felt in southern Ireland and southwest England, was strongly felt by
ships that navigated off the Finisterre cape (Philos. Trans. Roy. Soc. London,
1761; p. 421), reinforces the hypothesis that this earthquake was not an
aftershock of the 1755 earthquake, having epicentre in another area, probably
in the Galiza Bank region. Detail about this earthquake are given in Tabb.
3 and 4. More data are given by Moreira (1989).
Contacts with the "Institut Scientifique de
Rabat" were established. No data about the 27 Dec. 1722 were found in Morocco.
It is nearly sure that this earthquake was not felt in that country (Dr.
Cherkaoui, personal communication).
However, in the research carried out in Portugal
and Spain was found some more information about the 27 Dec. 1722 earthquake
to join to that already available in the basic catalogue above referred.
This information is concerned with the effects of the earthquake in Lisbon,
where it is now known that, at least, bells rung in a church situated in
the eastern part of the city (Belém, 1750; p. 200) and in Seville
(AMSev, XVIII).
Mainland Portugal |
Felt all over the country at about 12 o'clock.
Damage in several places especially in old buildings. At Oporto opened cracks in almost every houses. At a village about 20 miles from Oporto 3 or 4 houses were destroyed and some people killed. Was strong in Coimbra. In Lisbon was largely felt, but was not so violent as the earthquake of 1 Nov. 1755. A few old houses were thrown down and some ones cracked. New buildings at Rua Augusta (Lisboa) underwent damage. In Setubal several buildings were overthrown. In Évora it opened some cracks. |
Spain |
Felt in Madrid, where it shook the houses throwing
down the furnitures. Felt in Aranjuez, Alcalá la Real and Jaen. |
Ireland | In Cork an earthquake was felt at a quarter after noon. Was considered to be more violent than that of 1 Nov. 1755. |
United Kingdom |
The Lock Ness rose about 2 feet in the afternoon
and continued alternately rising and falling for the space of three quarters
of an hour. Similar to the 1 Nov. 1755. |
France | Felt at Bayonne and Bordeaux (Perrey, 1847). |
Netherlands | At Amsterdam the lamps of the synagogue and of the Maesland Church were observed to vibrate between one and two o'clock. |
PLACE | TIME | EFFECTS |
Some leagues of the shore from Lisbon, lat. 43o | 10 min. a.m. |
Violent shock. It shook the needle off the spindle of the compass. |
Off Lisbon; 44o 29' N; 11o 19' W | The ship shook so dreadfully that the crew threw out the boat in order to leave her. | |
Several leagues to the west of Cape Finisterre | It appeared that the ship had struck on sunken rocks. | |
It was felt more violently on the ocean, between the coasts of Spain and the British Channel. |
With the data now available was possible to
draw the isosseismal map shown in Fig. 3.
On the other hand no contemporary data were
found in Morocco about the so-called 1731 Agadir earthquake and corresponding
tsunami (Dr. Cherkaoui, personal communication), what places this earthquake
in the category of the doubtful ones. The only source known is Verneur (1822);
he reports that an earthquake destroyed the city of Santa Cruz (Agadir).
Although this document was published about one
century after the event,that information has been copied by several authors,
as Perrey (1847), Galbis Rodríguez (1932) and others (Cherkaoui, personal
communication). Taher (1979), who consulted a considerable number of arab
documentation, to prepare his catalogue, does not mention this earthquake.
Conclusions
As a result of the research carried out in several
archives in southern Portugal in 1989 and 1990 and in the National Archive
of Torre do Tombo in Lisbon in 1990 and 1991 some new data were found. This
data refer essentially to:
a) some information about several small
earthquakes,
b) new data about the Setubal earthquake of
June 1769, till now considered to be an obscure earthquake only felt slightly
in Lisbon,
c) development of the information about the
31 March 1761 earthquake leading to the establishment of a new position of
the epicentre giving up the classical hypothesis that considered this earthquake
as a late aftershock of the 1 Nov. 1755 earthquake,
d) new data about the 27 Dec. 1722 earthquake.
It is now known that this earthquake was slightly felt in Seville (Gonzalez
Jiménez, 1990; Lopez Arroyo, 1990) and in Lisbon and probably was
not felt in Morocco,
e) new data were collected about precursory
phenomena of the 1 Nov. 1755 earthquake. This achievement is one the most
important obtained in the frame of this project because this new data reveal
to have high interest in the important problem of earthquake prediction.
The data obtained till now as a result of this
research reveal to have high interest for the improvement of the knowledge
of the seismicity of the Gulf of Cadiz area and constitute an important
contribution for the preparation of the Portuguese National Seismic
Catalogue.
Acknowledgements
Many thanks are due to Mrs. Maria Jerónima
Taquelim and Mrs. Maria de Lourdes Aleixo for the contribution in the research
carried out in archives and libraries which revealed very useful for the
execution of the project. Thanks are extended to Mr. Colaço who drew
the figures.
References
Amezua, F. Lopez de, 1755. Carta philosophica.
Madrid.
AMSev (Archivo Municipal de Sevilla), XVIII.
Papeles del Conde del Aguila, 3, 11.
ANTT (Arquivo Nacional da Torre do Tombo,
Lisboa), 1776-1808. Convento de Sta. Clara, Évora, Livro de foros
e rendas, 35.
Belém, Fr. J. de, 1750. Chronica Serafica
da Santa Provincia dos Algarves, da Regular Observancia do Nosso Senhor Padre
S. Francisco, Em que se trata de sua Origem, Progressos e Fundações
de seus Conventos, Parte Primeira. Lisboa.
Ferrão, N., 1989a. Relatório
da pesquisa efectuada no arquivo histórico de Loulé (INMG internal
report).
Ferrão, N., 1989b. Relatório
da pesquisa efectuada na biblioteca pública, arquivo distrital de
Évora (INMG final report, Annex 1).
Ferrão, N., 1990a. Relatório
da pesquisa efectuada entre Dezembro e Janeiro - 89/90 (INMG final report,
Annex 2).
Ferrão, N., 1990b. Pesquisa de fontes
históricas. Projecto e progressão (INMG annual report 1990,
Annex 1).
Galbis Rodríguez, J., 1932. Catálogo
Sísmico. Inst. Geog. Catastral y de Estadística, Madrid.
Gonzalez Jiménez, M., 1990. Terremotos
en Sevilla (siglo XVIII). Informe (INMG report 1990, Annex 3).
Kant, I.M., 1910a.Von den Ursachen der
Erderschütterungen bei Gelegenheit des Unglückes, welches die
westlichen Länder von Europa gegen das Ende des voriges Jahres betroffen
hat. In: "Kants Werke", Vorkritische Schriften, vol 1. Königlich Preussiche
Akademie der Wissenschaften, Berlin.
Kant, I.M., 1910b. Geschichte und
Naturbeschreibung der merkwürdigsten Vorfälle des Erdbebens, welches
am Ende des 1755sten Jahres einen grossen Teil der Erde erschüttert
hat. In: "Kants Werke", Vorkritische Schriften, vol 1. Königlich Preussiche
Akademie der Wissenschaften, Berlin.
Lopez Arroyo, A. (Editor), 1990. La sismicidad
historica del Golfo de Cadiz (primera mitad del siglo XVIII) (INMG final
report, Annex 3).
Mezcua, J. y Martinez Solares, J.M., 1983.
Sismicidad del área Ibero-Mogrebí. I.G.N., Madrid.
Montandon, F., 1953. Les tremblements de
terre destructeurs in Europe. Genève.
Moreira de Mendonça, J.J., 1758.
História Universal dos Terremotos. Lisboa.
Moreira, V. Sousa, 1984. Sismicidade
histórica de Portugal Continental. Inst. Nac. Meteor. Geofísica,
Lisboa.
Moreira, V. Sousa, 1989. Review of the historical
seismicity in the gulf of Cadiz area before the 1 Nov. 1755 earthquake. A
CEC project. First report, INMG Lisboa.
Moreira, V. Sousa, 1991. Sismicidade
histórica de Portugal Continental. 2nd ed., Inst. Nac. Meteor.
Geofísica, Lisboa.
Moreira, V. Sousa, 1992. Review of the historical
seismicity in the Gulf of Cadiz area before the 1 Nov. 1755 earthquake. A
CEC project. Annual report, 1991 INMG Lisboa.
Moreira, V. Sousa, 1990. Review of the historical
seismicity in the gulf of Cadiz area before de 1 Nov. 1755 earthquake. A
CEC project. Annual report, 1990 NMG Lisboa.
Pereira de Sousa, F.L., 1919-32. O terremoto
do 1° de Novembro de 1755 em Portugal e um estudo demográfico,
Vol. I-IV. Lisboa.
Perrey, A., 1847. Sur les tremblements de
terre de la Peninsule Ibérique. Annales des sciences physiques et
naturelles, d'agriculture et d'industrie, X. Societé Royale d'agriculture,
d'histoire naturelle et des arts utiles, Lyon.
Runa, L. e Morais Freire, A.G., 1985.
Transcrições das respostas dos párocos ao inquérito
do Marquês de Pombal (manuscript reports).
Taher, Mostafa Anwar, 1979. Corpus de textes
arabes relatifs aux tremblements de terre et autres catastrophes naturelles
de la conquête arabe au XII H/XVIII J.C. Thèse de doctorat d'etat.
Université Paris I.
Themudo Barata, M.R., Braga, L., Noronha
Wagner, M., Guerra, B., Félix Alves, J. e Neto, J., 1988. Sismicidade
de Portugal. Estudo da documentação dos séculos XVII
e XVIII. I - Heurística, crítica e interpretação.
GPSN, Lisboa.
Themudo Barata, M.R., Braga, L., Noronha
Wagner, M., Guerra, B., Félix Alves, J. e Neto, J., 1989. Sismicidade
de Portugal. Estudo da documentação dos séculos XVII
e XVIII. II - Apêndice documental. GPSN, Lisboa.
Verneur, 1822. Journal des Voyages, tome
XV.
[Top]
[Vol.1]
[Vol.2]
[Deliverables and queries]
[Presentation]
[Homepage]